Rumination: When Thinking Becomes the Storm
There’s a certain kind of tired that doesn’t make sense until you’ve lived it.
You’re exhausted. Your body is asking for sleep. Everything in you wants to power down. And still, the moment your head hits the pillow, your mind acts like it just clocked in for a night shift.
It starts small. A conversation you replay to see if you said something wrong. A plan you run through one more time. A worry you try to “think out” like it’s a math problem with a correct answer.
And then the loop gets momentum.
You analyze. You prepare. You predict. You scroll through the past and the future like your mind is flipping through channels, trying to find the one that will finally let you rest.
If you’ve ever laid there wide awake, not because you aren’t tired, but because your thoughts won’t shut down, this might sound familiar.
There’s a name for it.
This is rumination.
Why rumination feels like it’s helping
Rumination is convincing because it feels responsible.
The brain mistakes thinking for problem-solving. It treats thought like action. And in a nervous system that’s learned to stay alert, thinking feels like doing something. Like protecting yourself. Like staying one step ahead.
Underneath rumination is a belief the brain rarely questions: If I keep thinking, I’ll stay safe.
The problem is that the brain doesn’t actually know the difference between useful thinking and repetitive thinking. It only knows activity. So it keeps generating thoughts, scanning for threats, replaying moments, and running scenarios, not because it’s productive, but because it believes stopping would be dangerous.
That’s why rumination feels involuntary. You’re not choosing to think. Your nervous system is choosing for you.
It can feel like control.
It can feel like preparation.
And sometimes it even feels like progress.
But most of the time, it’s motion without movement. The same thoughts circle. The same worries deepen their grooves. And the brain never gets the signal it’s been waiting for: We’re safe now.
The cost of the loop
The problem with rumination isn’t that you’re thinking.
It’s that you’re thinking in circles.
Rumination drains energy. It increases anxiety. It keeps the nervous system activated, like an alarm that never fully shuts off. And over time, it starts to affect everything, not just your nights.
You can be exhausted and still not feel safe enough to rest.
That’s why insomnia isn’t always about sleep itself. Sometimes it’s about safety. Sometimes the body is tired, but the mind hasn’t been told it’s okay to stop scanning.
And here’s the paradox I’ve noticed.
The more tired we get, the harder the mind tries to think its way out.
It’s like the brain hears exhaustion and says, “Fine. We’ll solve this faster.” And then it speeds up. It pushes harder. It loops tighter.
And you wake up the next day feeling like you ran a marathon in your head.
Where rumination comes from
Rumination usually doesn’t show up for no reason.
A lot of the time, it grows in places where vigilance was necessary. Anxiety. Trauma. Unpredictable environments. Past moments where being on alert felt like survival.
When you’ve lived in a world where you had to read the room, anticipate the reaction, or stay ready for the next shift in mood, your nervous system learns something.
It learns that “relaxed” is risky.
For people with trauma, rumination often turns into reliving.
The brain doesn’t store traumatic memories the same way it stores ordinary ones. Instead of being filed away as something that happened, they stay close to the surface, unfinished and unresolved.
So the mind keeps returning to them.
Not because it wants to suffer, but because it’s trying to make sense of something that never felt safe enough to complete.
This is why some people feel like they’re reliving the same moments all day, every day. The past doesn’t feel like the past. It feels current. Active. Still happening.
In those cases, rumination isn’t about solving a problem.
It’s about a nervous system that never got the chance to stand down.
Rumination is learned. And that matters, because it means you didn’t choose it to be difficult. It once served a purpose. It was your mind trying to keep you steady in a world that didn’t feel steady.
There’s no shame in that.
Illusion vs reality
Some things can be solved with thought.
And some things can only be lived through.
Rumination creates a quiet illusion that every feeling has a solution, and that the solution lives in thought.
But many emotions don’t resolve through thinking. They resolve through safety, time, and presence.
When we try to think our way out of fear, grief, or uncertainty, the mind works harder instead of softer. It searches for certainty in places where certainty doesn’t exist.
That’s the illusion.
Not that thinking is bad, but that thinking is always the right tool.
Sometimes the mind is trying to use a hammer where only rest will work.
But reality is quieter than that.
Life has parts that can’t be managed into peace. Parts that can’t be reasoned into certainty. Parts that simply unfold, whether we’re ready or not.
Rumination is what happens when the mind tries to use thinking to create guarantees.
And the hard truth is, there aren’t always guarantees.
Sometimes the most peaceful thing we can do is stop demanding certainty from a day that was never designed to offer it.
Control and letting go
Rumination tends to attach itself to things we can’t control.
Other people’s choices. Old moments we wish went differently. Future outcomes we can’t predict. Conversations we can’t redo. Timing we can’t speed up.
And the mind, being the mind, tries anyway.
Letting go isn’t hard because we’re stubborn.
It’s hard because the brain equates control with safety.
When control disappears, the nervous system hears danger. So it responds by thinking harder, replaying more, scanning faster.
Rumination is often the mind’s attempt to regain control in situations where control was never available to begin with.
Peace often begins when we shift our attention from what we can’t control to what we can.
Not in a forced way. Not in a “just focus on the positive” way. More like a gentle pivot. A small redirect. A choice to come back to what is actually in our hands right now.
We’ll go deeper into control in a future post, because it matters more than we realize.
For now, it’s enough to notice the direction your thoughts keep pulling you.
Reflection vs rumination
Not all thinking is bad.
Some thinking is reflection. And reflection can be healthy.
Reflection has space. It leads to insight. It ends naturally. It might bring clarity, or a lesson, or even a sense of closure.
Rumination feels different.
Rumination feels urgent. It feels endless. It loops.
Reflection tends to open something up.
Rumination tends to tighten everything down.
If you’ve ever noticed the difference in your body, you already know what I mean. Reflection might feel like a slow walk.
Rumination feels like pacing a hallway.
What helps interrupt the cycle
The goal isn’t to stop thoughts.
The goal is to change your relationship with them.
A lot of the time, the first shift is simply noticing the loop.
Not judging it. Not fighting it. Just catching yourself in it.
Oh. I’m doing it again.
Sometimes that small moment of awareness is the beginning of relief.
Sometimes it helps to come back into the body. To notice your shoulders. Your jaw. Your breath. To feel your feet on the floor. To ground yourself in the present moment, not because the present moment is perfect, but because it’s real.
And yes, meditation can help. But not because it empties the mind.
Meditation isn’t about forcing silence inside your head.
It’s about training the nervous system to recognize that thoughts are happening without needing to follow them.
Over time, this creates space. Not by stopping thoughts, but by loosening their grip.
We’ll go much deeper into this in the next post, because for people who live in their heads, this skill can change everything.
An ordinary moment of release
One of the quietest times I notice rumination is in the morning.
Coffee in hand. House still waking up. And my brain already halfway into the day, planning, worrying, reviewing.
And sometimes I catch it.
Not because I’m disciplined. Not because I’m enlightened. Just because I finally feel how tense my shoulders are, or how shallow my breathing got without me noticing.
So I take one breath.
Not a magical breath. Just a real one.
And in that one breath, something softens. Just a little.
The thought doesn’t disappear, but I stop chasing it.
And that’s usually how relief arrives. Not with fireworks. Not with some big breakthrough.
Quietly.
You’re not broken, you’re tired
If you live with rumination, it doesn’t mean you’re failing.
It means your mind learned to stay active because it thought it had to.
Your mind isn’t your enemy.
It’s just tired. And it’s been trying.
Rest is allowed.
Even if your thoughts are loud.
Even if you don’t feel perfectly calm.
Even if you have to come back to it a hundred times.
Rumination doesn’t mean something is wrong with you.
It means your nervous system hasn’t learned yet that it’s allowed to rest.
When thinking becomes the storm, rest is the harbor.
And if today is one of those days where you don’t have the energy to “fix” anything, that’s okay. Sometimes you let the day be what it is. Sometimes you make it to bedtime and call that a win.
We’ll try again tomorrow.
You’re not broken.
You’re tired.
Anchor your mind. Find your harbor.
If You’d Like Additional Support
If rumination, overthinking, or mental looping has been weighing on you, you don’t have to figure it out alone. The resources below offer clear, grounded information and support if you want to explore further.
-
Anxiety & Depression Association of America (ADAA)
Education and resources on anxiety, rumination, and repetitive thought patterns, written in a clear and approachable way.
https://adaa.org
National Institute of Mental Health (NIMH)
Research-based information on anxiety, trauma, and mental health conditions, explained in plain language.
https://www.nimh.nih.gov
-
International OCD Foundation (IOCDF)
Helpful resources on intrusive thoughts and rumination, even for those without OCD.
https://iocdf.org -
Psychology Today – Therapist Directory
A searchable directory to help find licensed, trauma-informed therapists who work with anxiety and rumination.
https://www.psychologytoday.com
These are here if you want them. There’s no pressure to do anything right now.
Some Useful Reading: